Disclaimer
This information collection is a core HTA, i.e. an extensive analysis
of one or more health technologies using all nine domains of the HTA Core Model.
The core HTA is intended to be used as an information base for local
(e.g. national or regional) HTAs.
Immunoglobulins (IGG) compared to placebo, not doing anything or Usual supportive care in the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease in elderly AD is diagnosed mostly in people over 65 years of age, although there is an early-onset form that can occur much earlier. According to Wikipedia in 2006, there were 26.6 million sufferers worldwide.
(See detailed scope below)
Authors: Pseudo117 Pseudo117, Pseudo451 Pseudo451, Pseudo136 Pseudo136, Pseudo262 Pseudo262
It is not possible to determine with certainty whether use of Intravenous immunoglobulins for Alzheimer disease including Mild Cognitive Impairment affects significantly organisational aspects.
The current overview can be used as a starting point for further research on the organisational impact of use of Intravenous immunoglobulins for Alzheimer disease including Mild Cognitive Impairment.
The most issues of this domain should not be included in the HTA on the “Use of Intravenous immunoglobulins for Alzheimer disease including Mild Cognitive Impairment”.
From a organisational point of view the “Health Problem and Current Use of the Technology” domain, “Description and technical characteristics of technology” domain already includes the use and technical characteristics of technology.
For Mild Cognitive Impairment, and Moderate to Severe there is no available evidence, while for Mild to Moderate Alzheimer disease there is upcoming evidence.
The technology under assessment is still in its early stage of development and evidence based answers to the AEs of ORG domain we selected during the protocol, cannot be given. On the other hand decisions about their use for treating one category of patients or another rise ethical questions related to how to use limited resources (ETH domain).
The collection scope is used in this domain.
Technology | Immunoglobulins (IGG)
DescriptionNaturally occurring proteins produced by the body’s immune system to combat foreign antigens |
---|---|
Intended use of the technology | Treatment Treatment of Alzheimer’s disease Target conditionAlzheimer’s diseaseTarget condition descriptionAlzheimer's disease (AD) or Alzheimer disease, is the most common form of dementia. There is no cure for the disease, which worsens as it progresses, and eventually leads to death. Target populationTarget population sex: Any. Target population age: elderly. Target population group: Patients who have the target condition. Target population descriptionAD is diagnosed mostly in people over 65 years of age, although there is an early-onset form that can occur much earlier. According to Wikipedia in 2006, there were 26.6 million sufferers worldwide. |
Comparison | placebo, not doing anything or Usual supportive care
DescriptionThere is no MA for IGGs for AD yet and there is no other intervention licensed for use in AD so the comparison would have to be against placebo or best supportive care |
Outcomes |
|
Topic | Issue | Relevant | Research questions or rationale for irrelevance | |
---|---|---|---|---|
G0001 | Health delivery process | How does the technology affect the current work processes? | yes | How does IGG affect the current work processes? |
G0100 | Health delivery process | What kind of patient/participant flow is associated with the new technology? | yes | What kind of patient/participant flow is associated with IGG? |
G0002 | Health delivery process | What kind of involvement has to be mobilized for patients/participants and important others? | yes | What kind of involvement has to be mobilized for patients/participants and important others? |
G0003 | Health delivery process | What is the process ensuring proper education and training of the staff? | yes | What is the process ensuring proper education and training of the staff? |
G0004 | Health delivery process | What kind of co-operation and communication of activities have to be mobilised? | yes | What kind of co-operation and communication of activities have to be mobilised? |
G0012 | Health delivery process | How is the quality assurance and monitoring system of the new technology organised? | yes | How is the quality assurance and monitoring system of IGG organised? |
G0005 | Structure of health care system | How does de-centralisation or centralization requirements influence the implementation of the technology? | yes | How does de-centralisation or centralization requirements influence the implementation of IGG? |
G0101 | Structure of health care system | What are the processes ensuring access to care of the new technology for patients/participants? | yes | What are the processes ensuring access to care of IGG for patients/participants? |
G0006 | Process-related costs | What are the processes related to purchasing and setting up the new technology? | yes | What are the processes related to purchasing and setting up IGG? |
G0007 | Process-related costs | What are the likely budget impacts of implementing the technologies being compared? | yes | What are the likely budget impacts of implementing the technologies being compared? |
G0008 | Management | What management problems and opportunities are attached to the technology? | yes | What management problems and opportunities are attached to IGG? |
G0009 | Management | Who decides which people are eligible for the technology and on what basis? | yes | Who decides which people are eligible for intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) therapy and on what basis? |
G0010 | Culture | How is the technology accepted? | yes | How is IGG accepted? |
G0011 | Culture | How are the other interest groups taken into account in the planning / implementation of the technology? | yes | How are the other interest groups taken into account in the planning / implementation of IGG? |
The project scope is applied in this domain.
Currently, IVIG is not an approved as a treatment option in Mild Cognitive Impairment and Alzheimer’s disease (AD), therefore there are no relevant clinical guidelines on its position in the treatment pathway (for example whether it would replace existing pharmacological and other interventions or constitute an add-on therapy).
In terms of its impact on the patient pathway, with regard to AD, IVIG has a different route of administration compared to pharmacological treatments used in the management of AD. In specific, administration of IVIG for its approved indications is mainly done in the hospital setting or in infusion clinics ({White-Reid K, 2008}{1}, although depending on the clinical characteristics of the patients, alternative site of care (GP office, home care) can be used.
Taking into consideration recommendations on IVIG use for its licensed indications, patients may also need to undergo pre-treatment testing and routine monitoring for development of complications after treatment with IVIG {Silvergleid and Berger} {2}. Finally, delayed disease progression would affect AD prevalence and consequently impact the service delivery models {Brodaty el al}{ {3}.
Refer to TEC 4, TEC 5, TEC8.
Importance: Critical
Transferability: Partially
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) is administered by infusion, predominantly in the hospital setting.
Since it is a product with limited availability and high cost, special management programs may be in place regarding its administration to patients such as the Department of Health Demand Management Plan for Immunoglobulin Use in the UK{Department of Health} {4}, the Immunoglobulin (Ig) Governance Program in Australia {National Blood Authority} {5} or the IVIG Utilization Management Program ran by the BC Provincial Blood Coordinating Office (PBCO) in Canada {Provincial Health Services Authority} {6}. Management programs may also be in place at the regional or the hospital level.
According to instructions relating to its administration in other groups of patients for its licensed indications in the aforementioned jurisdictions, patient written consent is required. Information provided to the patients relates to immunoglobulin products; reason for treatment; how the products are given; risks and benefits of the treatment; alternative treatments; side effects; and also requirements regarding collection and sharing of personal private information that apply for IVIG administration. Patients must also have instructions on how to act if serious reactions after treatment appear.
Importance: Important
Transferability: Not
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
There is not information available about management problems of IVIGs for AD as this treatment has not been approved for AD but as an experimental therapy. In general, for various other conditions there is some information. The IVIG therapy is usually administered in hospitals or hospital-based outpatient clinics under clinical protocols, and is usually based on national policies {National Blood Authority} {7}.
By the management viewpoint the most critical points is to ensure availability of the IVIG products. There could be problems within the supply of IVIG. It is prepared from the purified plasma immunoglobulins of large numbers of healthy donors. The process of plasma into IVIG takes about 9 months. Solution to the problems of supply includes new manufacturing process, use of recombinant technology to produce IVIG, or an administration of specific antibodies in place of IVIG { Loeffler} {8}.
In addition, it has to be ensured that there are appropriate policies and procedures for the whole process. For example, IVIG products need specific storage and prescribing requirements and detailed documentation of infusions. {National Blood Authority} {7} (Refer to TEC 7 and TEC 10).
Adequate training and skills of the personnel have to be ensured. The personnel need specific knowledge and skills of treating patients with IVIG. Training of administrating IVG includes e.g. knowledge of infusion technique and use of equipment, as well as identification of possible adverse reactions of the product. (Refer to TEC 13).
Importance: Important
Transferability: Partially
As IVIG have not been approved for Alzheimer’s disease including Mild Cognitive Impairment, IVIG therapy does not have a formal prescription pathway for such indications. Considering the contextual differences among the countries, a generalisation of the off-label prescription strategies of the IVIG therapy is not possible and remains out of the scope of the present results card.
The current setting for the administration of IVIG therapy (for any condition) is use within hospitals {Appendix CUR-3}.
Importance: Important
Transferability: Completely
None of our included studies provided information on this topic.
Importance: Unspecified
Transferability: Unspecified
IVIG is an experimental therapy for AD and therefore there is not information about stakeholders.
In Australia {National Blood Authority} {7}, the key stakeholders involved with the supply, prescribing, dispensing, administration and use of IVIG are:
Importance: Important
Transferability: Partially
According to the information available at the time of writing, IVIG are not used for Alzheimer’s disease including Mild Cognitive Impairment in any of the EUnetHTA partners, and is quite difficult to find available information on the organizational aspects.